Beef Stew Recipe

Back to Beef Stew All Reviews for Beef Stew - of Reviews Reviews: Most Helpful Most Helpful Most Positive Least Positive Newest

Gallery Read the full recipe after the video. Recipe Summary prep: 15 mins total: 2 hrs 45 mins Servings: 6 beef stew with vegetables

Ingredients Ingredient Checklist 3 pounds beef chuck, trimmed of visible fat and cut into 1 1/2-inch cubes 1/3 cup tomato paste 3 tablespoons balsamic vinegar 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour Coarse salt and ground pepper 1 pound medium onions (about 2), cut into 1-inch chunks 1 pound small white or red new potatoes (about 6), well scrubbed, halved if large 1 pound carrots, cut into 1 1/2-inch lengths 6 garlic cloves, smashed 2 bay leaves

Cook’s Notes Freeze individual-size servings of your beef stew, and turn leftovers into a great lunch or dinner. Variations Slow-Cooker Variation: Place beef in a 5-quart slow cooker. Distribute tomato paste, vinegar, and flour over beef; season generously with salt and pepper. Add onions, potatoes, carrots, garlic, and bay leaves. Cover slow cooker; cook on high until beef is fork-tender, about 5 hours (or cook on low heat 8 hours).

Gallery Read the full recipe after the video.

Recipe Summary prep: 15 mins total: 2 hrs 45 mins Servings: 6 beef stew with vegetables

Gallery

Read the full recipe after the video.

Read the full recipe after the video.

Recipe Summary prep: 15 mins total: 2 hrs 45 mins Servings: 6

Recipe Summary

prep: 15 mins total: 2 hrs 45 mins

Servings: 6

prep: 15 mins

total: 2 hrs 45 mins

prep:

15 mins

total:

2 hrs 45 mins

Servings: 6

6

beef stew with vegetables

beef stew with vegetables

Ingredients

Ingredients

• 3 pounds beef chuck, trimmed of visible fat and cut into 1 1/2-inch cubes 1/3 cup tomato paste 3 tablespoons balsamic vinegar 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour Coarse salt and ground pepper 1 pound medium onions (about 2), cut into 1-inch chunks 1 pound small white or red new potatoes (about 6), well scrubbed, halved if large 1 pound carrots, cut into 1 1/2-inch lengths 6 garlic cloves, smashed 2 bay leaves

Directions

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. In a Dutch oven (5-quart) with a tight-fitting lid, combine beef, tomato paste, vinegar, and flour; season with salt and pepper.

Add onions, potatoes, carrots, garlic, bay leaves, and 3 cups water. Bring to a boil. Cover, transfer to oven, and cook until meat is fork-tender, 2 to 2 1/2 hours. Remove bay leaves and, if desired, season with salt and pepper before serving.

Cook’s Notes Freeze individual-size servings of your beef stew, and turn leftovers into a great lunch or dinner.

Variations Slow-Cooker Variation: Place beef in a 5-quart slow cooker. Distribute tomato paste, vinegar, and flour over beef; season generously with salt and pepper. Add onions, potatoes, carrots, garlic, and bay leaves. Cover slow cooker; cook on high until beef is fork-tender, about 5 hours (or cook on low heat 8 hours).

Cook’s Notes

Freeze individual-size servings of your beef stew, and turn leftovers into a great lunch or dinner.

Variations

Slow-Cooker Variation: Place beef in a 5-quart slow cooker. Distribute tomato paste, vinegar, and flour over beef; season generously with salt and pepper. Add onions, potatoes, carrots, garlic, and bay leaves. Cover slow cooker; cook on high until beef is fork-tender, about 5 hours (or cook on low heat 8 hours).

Reviews (112)

 Add Rating & Review     2254 Ratings   5 star values:        329    4 star values:        465    3 star values:        879    2 star values:        471    1 star values:        110        

Load More Reviews

Reviews (112)

Add Rating & Review     2254 Ratings   5 star values:        329    4 star values:        465    3 star values:        879    2 star values:        471    1 star values:        110       

Add Rating & Review

2254 Ratings 5 star values: 329 4 star values: 465 3 star values: 879 2 star values: 471 1 star values: 110

2254 Ratings 5 star values: 329 4 star values: 465 3 star values: 879 2 star values: 471 1 star values: 110

2254 Ratings 5 star values: 329 4 star values: 465 3 star values: 879 2 star values: 471 1 star values: 110

• 5 star values: 329 4 star values: 465 3 star values: 879 2 star values: 471 1 star values: 110

  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 5.0 stars       12/26/2019   Thank you for cutting an onion properly in the video. I hate when I see an onion being prepped incorrectly. There is no reason for vertical cuts into an onion before chopping. If you cut an onion in half from stem to root, the onion does the work for you. You just need to make the horizontal cuts on the outside and then chop away.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 5 stars       11/03/2019   I love this recipe! I think it's because of the vinegar, the meat is nice and tender.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 5 stars       10/06/2019   I/we really enjoyed this. For just 2 of us, 2 lbs of the beef chuck worked out fine. And I also added 2 celery stalks - cut in the 1-1/2" length too. I thought I had an onion, but it was good without it. I normally would have cooked a stew on the stove top. I followed the recipe here and brought it to a boil and then into the oven. I think this really made a difference for me. The meat was incredibly tender. What I would do next time..."up" the tomato paste/balsamic vinegar/flour mixture by about 1/3, and then add another cup of water. Why? We'd like more gravy! It's a keeper!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 5 stars       06/26/2019   So I don’t have a slow cooker and big shock confession, I’m a vegan. But I followed the ingredients replacing beef with vegan beef pieces from gardein. I cut the veggies and sautéed them in oil in a pot while I cooked the vegan beef and then added it to the softened veggies with 3 cups of vegan beef stock. Once boiled I lowered the heat and let it simmer for an hour. I also add about 6 stalks of celery chopped and it is so delicious.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 1 stars       02/28/2019   This was not good for us. Me, my wife, 3 kids and our Au Pair couldn't make it through a serving. Everybody just kind of pushed it around in their bowls. I made it in the slow cooker and followed the recipe. The balsamic vinegar gave it a sharp bitter taste that did not meld will with the bay leaf and tomato paste. The dish was lacking in flavor and depth and the flavor that it did have was described to me as acrid and bitter. Ours did not thicken and was watery. Didn't look at all like the video. 6 hours in a slow cooker on high and I still had to put it in the IP to finish it. Won't be doing this one again.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 5 stars       01/27/2019   I made this beef stew recipe yesterday in my crock pot and it was absolutely delicious. I followed the recipe exactly as suggested and didn't change anything. I have tried many other beef stew recipes in the past and none of them were as delicious as this one. It was easy to prepare and it is a recipe that I will share with my family and friends. Thank you very much for such an easy and delicious recipe for beef stew!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 5 stars       11/13/2018   LOVED IT! The only alteration made was 3 cups of organic beef broth instead of the water and little potatoes the size of golf balls instead of cut potatoes. And, it only took 2 hours in the oven with my Le Creuset. My guests raved on and on of the taste and beauty of the stew. Thank you for posting such a grand recipe.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       10/01/2014   I've been using this beef stew recipe for a few years now and I love it! I make it in the crock pot. The only thing I change is that I add additional flour to the beef in the beginning as I like my beef stew thick. I also add a can of beef broth or french onion soup. It comes out perfect every time.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       03/07/2014   I make this frequently in the slow cooker, but take the extra time to brown my beef in a skillet and deglaze the pan with some red wine before I assemble the ingredients per the recipe's instructions. I also add celery and extra garlic cloves/potatoes/carrots, just because of personal preference. It always turns out extremely well. It's so easy, even with the extra step, and gives a huge flavor payoff. I have never tried the dutch oven version because I don't have the best oven (renter).  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/17/2014   I've been making this recipe for years. It's in constant rotation for my winter recipes. It's simple and delicious. I've made it in both a crockpot and dutch oven and prefer the dutch oven method.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/30/2014   Great spring board recipe! The balsamic vinegar definitely gives this stew a tasty kick. I do this in the oven vs. crock pock and instead of adding water, I bump it up and add 2 cups of beef stock and 1 cup of red wine. After 2 hours I throw in a package of quartered baby bella mushrooms and a few handfuls of fresh string beans, trimmed and cut into 1 inch pieces. You can also throw in a handful of frozen peas at the end as well. One dish wonder and oh so good.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/04/2014   As a relatively new "cook", I try to follow the recipes to a T but I read the review beforehand for an overall impression. I have never used a slow cooker before but it worked very well. No water was needed and there was plenty of moisture created by the ingredients themselves. I felt that the amount of carrots and onions were heavy. This dish was tasty immediately afterwards; however, re-heated, it lacked its original flavor and texture. A keeper but not on a regular rotation.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 5 stars       12/20/2013   This recipe is perfect , easy , delicious and exactly what I was looking for .  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 3 stars       11/26/2013   Very very simple and tasty without going to much trouble. I made this in the crock pot using a little over 1 and 1/2 lbs lean stew beef, halved the potatoes and carrots, substituted 8 oz frozen pearl onions for chopped, and added 8 oz sliced cremini mushrooms. Also added some celery seed and dried basil and oregano. Cooked on high for 5 hours. Will probably add a little red wine next time because I would like more gravy. A little crumbled bacon would probably be a nice touch, too.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       10/23/2013   The slow cooker recipe doesn't say anything about adding water??? I just added it anyway and started it. Sure hope it's right!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       10/04/2013   Remove bay leaf? My grandmother always said "whoever gets the bay leaf has to kiss the cook".  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 4 stars       09/22/2013   I was looking for a recipe just like this one. Foolproof, tasty and so simple that it wouldn't take ages to make. Never mind browning meat and wasting time - just mix the first group of ingredients together over medium heat, add the rest of it and plunk it in the oven. That's it! SO delicious and absolutely tastes like you spent HOURS making it! Will absolutely be making again!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       09/15/2013   Cooked a pound of bacon first, browned meat in bacon fat. Then sauteed mushrooms in fat and de-glazed pot with a can of beef stock. Then added onions, potaotes, 3 tblsp soy sauce, 1 tblsp anchovy paste and a bottle of Cabernet. Put in oven at 300 for 4 hours. YOWZA! So beefy and delicious. Super easy. Took about 30 min to get it into the oven.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       07/05/2013   Thanks! When the weather gets cooler I will be making this beef stew. Thanks for posting! Looks like an easy to make recipe.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 2 stars       04/26/2013   In spite of alll of the ingredients cooking up perfectly. the meat was tender, the carrots and potatoes were perfect, this dish was just ok to me, but my husband liked it. I shared with a friend and she said that although it had some kick to it she still liked it. I thought it was too salty and just not colorful enough. The flavors didn't excite me. My list of what I didn't like about this dish is too long so I'll just say I won't be making it again. To be fair -- I just don't think I like beef stew.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       03/27/2013   What makes this recipe great is its simplicity. Yeah, there are some better recipes out there, but its hard to beat this one on time and ingredient count. Brown the meat in bacon grease and add the cooked bacon for additional flavor. I recommend a thick cut maple smoked bacon for it because you can taste the difference in the end product. I used a slow cooker and found after several runs that the low setting is better than high. Fridge overnight for best results and reheat prior to eating.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       03/18/2013   Made this last night for the first - it was delicious and easy! I'm not generally a huge fan of stew, but boy this hit the spot on a cold night! I cooked in the oven for slightly over 2 hours and the meat and veggies were was tender but not mushy or overcooked in the least. I just served w/ hearty sliced bread. Perfect winter meal!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/13/2013   I also used my Le Creuset 7 qt pot in the oven at 2.5 hrs. It works perfectly and I prefer it over the slow cooker for retention of color and vitamins in the veg.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/13/2013   over 25 years making stew, and this is the simplest and most delicious result I have ever had!!! A few tweaks to personalize what my family likes- I use one cup beef stock in place of one of the cups of water. I use roasted garlic instead of raw, I use 1Tbs of fresh chopped Rosemary and 1 Tbs fresh Thyme leaves from my garden. I add one leek chopped (light green and white parts) in place of one of the onions. I use 1 Tbs. of Maple Balsamic Vinegar in place of one of the Tbs. of Balsamic. A+ EASY  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/08/2013   I did the low & slow (8hrs) in a slow cooker, and when I first took it out and tasted it, I really didn't like it. It tasted too much like vinegar and had no depth. I was making it for someone else the next day, so I put it in the fridge thinking I would try and "fix" it in the morning. The next day when I tasted it, it was fabulous! So, my advice is to let it sit a few hours or overnight to let the flavors meld. I dd the recipe as stated with the addition of 1/3 c beef broth. Really good!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/03/2013   Made this today (oven version). Husband and I loved it. Easy peasy, absolute perfection.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       12/27/2012   Made this the other night for the first time using the crockpot. Would have been excellent had I known to add 3 cups of water. The ingredient list or crockpot variation instructions so not say anything about water, which made my stew very very dry. Will definitley make this again, next time using water or beef stock and I know it will be delicious! They should really update this.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       12/05/2012   Made the stew last night in our crock pot, and it turned out wonderfully, with one addition-- I added a cup of a nice red wine and let it simmer away for about the last hour of cooking; added a nice depth to the flavor, and complimented the vinegar nicely. Have to say, this stew was a wonderful end to a rainy day.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/19/2012   A bit sweet. I didn't care for the tomato taste.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/18/2012   My family and I loved this dish. I made it in the oven instead of a slow cooker just so I could cut cooking time. The meal was super easy to make and an easy clean up! It's very hearty and filling and serves 8 easily. Just bought a fresh loaf to go along with it. I'll be sure to make this meal time and time again.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       09/26/2012   We absolutely loved this recipe! I did the slow cooker version & it was literally dump it all in there & forget about it! We have a very tight schedule on Wednesdays so I think this will definitely be going into my rotation. It was meaty-and the meat was soooooooo tender!-, it had a good serving of veggies in it. It was extremely flavorful, I seasoned the beef with seasoned salt before I put it in though, I will say I enjoy natural flavors over anyway. I served it with pretzel rolls!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 5 stars       03/31/2012   I used the Slow Cooker method of preparation at a low temperature for 8 hours and can assure confused readers that it is NOT necessary to add the 3 cups of water required for the stove-top/oven method: the ingredients provide their own liquid as the stew cooks. Otherwise, the only further comment I can make is that this is unquestionably the best beef stew I have ever prepared and recommend this recipe heartily without qualifications or additional suggestions.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/26/2012   Looks good. I usually add my potatoes and carrots after beef cooks 2 hours and cook the vegetables for 30 minutes. That way the vegetables aren't mushy.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       12/10/2011   I've tried this recipe on the stove and in the slow cooker. I definitely favored the slow cooker results. The meat came out a LOT more tender that way. I really jam pack the ingredients in because I'm usually feeding a crowd (plus this recipe reheats VERY well!) I found that the stove version of this stew made for less tender meat and mooshy veggies. I'd almost always suggest going for the crockpot version and using just a little liquid (either a cup of water or beef stock) Yum! A favorite!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/16/2011   i made this tonight in the crock pot for the first time and it was great! i think next time the carrots need to be cut in half because they were hard to keep on the fork. i didnt tell my husband that there was vinegar in it bc i knew he wouldnt be as open to trying it. he loved it and we both agreed that this was the best stew ive made yet. i didnt grow up liking stew so im slowly learning how to. i even ate leftovers which i never do! this is going into our favorites pile!!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/16/2011   also at the end of cooking, i took out about a 1/2C of the liquid and whisked in about 4 TB of flour. my husband likes his stew liquid a little thicker than what it originally came out as. then i added that to the stew and let it sit for about 10 minutes so the flour flavor could cook out. that made it the perfect consistancy for us!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/07/2011   Made it in the slow cooker for the first time tonight. It was a success. The meat was tender and vegetables were excellent. I added celery as an extra. In order to jazz it up a bit, next time we will add more seasoning. It looked just like the picture!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: 2 stars       06/11/2011   This recipe just did not work for me. It was bland, tasteless. I will give it 5 starts however, in part, because the meat was just about the most perfect I've ever had out of a slow cooker.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       03/03/2011   I made this the other night and it was very good and extremely easy. Next time I might change it from 3tbl of vinegar to 2 because the flavor was kind of strong. I'd also check on it about half way through and give it a stir because mine started to dry out on top a little. (I did the baked version) I added some peas at the end. Yum!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/01/2011   This was amazing! I made it on the stove top and instead of water, I used beef broth. Next time I'll use orange juice instead of balsamic vinegar for a different twist. Yummm!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/05/2011   Also, I forgot to mention in my previous comment, I cooked mine with a whole Axis rump roast instead of cubes!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/05/2011   Delicious!!!!! Cooked mine in a 7 qt. crockpot with loose lid and draped a towel over it, it came out perfect! But be sure to turn the heat down to low the last couple of hours cause I didn't and had to add 2 cups more water at serving time, but it was still YUMMY!!!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/02/2011   Loved this. I was nervous because I have a 7 qt. Crock pot with not the tightest-fitting lid. No need to worry... turned out great!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/20/2010   susansmeke: Thanks for you response! My dinner turned out quite yummy...I ended up giving it a stir because I had read that someone suggested adding peas in the last 15 minutes of cooking so I added them and gave it a stir. I let it cook for about 30 minutes longer after this. I think stirring helped to mix it all up too and really get the flavors into the veggies. I didn't add the water and it turned out fine. There was enough moisture that had seeped out from the ingredients :)  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/13/2010   I made this and it came out perfect. My oven tends to run a little hot, so I cooked it at 325. I added celery to add a little sweetness to it (my fam likes red onions, but I only had white so tried to compensate a little bit). Meat was tender and veggies were perfect. Thanks for a simple, great recipe!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/10/2010   OregonWinoFoodie: You are right, use a dutch oven and start it on the stovetop. When it comes to a boil transfer the pot to the oven. A dutch oven is designed for both stovetop and oven cooking and should have a tight fitting lid (one that wan't let all the juice escape in the form of steam.) Hopefully you have an enameled cast iron dutch oven - they're great and you don't have to spend $$$$. Martha Stewart has a nice one available at Macy's at a good price.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/10/2010   PS lilwbprincess: I don't know why the slow cooker version doesn't say to add the water, but hopefully you read the oven version and saw that you needed to add 3 cups of water. Hope your dinner was delicious!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/10/2010   lilwbprincess: You shouldn't have to stir this. A well written recipe should tell you just the order to put things into the pot and if it is necessary to stir half way through cooking. It rarley is necessary or suggested to stir during the cooking process in a slow cooker, because removing the lid lets a lot of heat escape and then it has to come back up to temperature. Then it is REALLY sloooww coooking;) The order of ingredients is calculated for even cooking, so important to follow.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/04/2010   For crockpot: do you stir the stew at all? Before turning on the pot? Halfway through? I'm a very beginner cook and I just have no clue about this stuff...I'm concerned that the meat will just cook and burn as the bottom layer and all the veggies sitting on top will dry out. I would appreciate any help anyone has :) (I actually just started it about 10 minutes ago, but I'd love to know if I'm supposed to mix everything for next time)  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       10/31/2010   I'm confused about the oven version... It says to bring the dish to a boil and then transfer to the oven. So I'm assuming you bring the stew to a boil on the stove and then transfer to the oven? I seem to be the only one confused about that!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       10/19/2010   So easy and very tasty. I did the slow-cooker variation, on high for 5 hours. The meat came out extremely tender, but the bottom layer was a little burnt. Not sure if it was the high temp, or if my crock pot is just crummy. Regardless, this is a great, simple recipe that I'll definitely make again.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       10/10/2010   Great recipe. I added celery and cut back the pepper. Brought the pot to a boil before sliding it into the thermos for 10 hours. Meat came out melt-in-your mouth soft. Veggies were perfect.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       05/24/2010   I made this beef stew last night and we had it for dinner today. It was so good, the best beef stew i ever ate. I cooked it in the dutch over. The vegetables and meet just melt in your mouth. Thank you for the great recipe!!!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       05/19/2010   I think this is terrific recipe. I do the dutch oven version and it consistently comes out great. It has a thick, hearty texture. You definitely need to be generous with the salt and pepper to bring out the flavor in the beef. It's super easy though and perfect if you want a hearty meal on a rainy or cold day.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/03/2009   My husband, 1-year old daughter and I all loved this recipe. I made the slow-cooker version and halved the recipe. It was really, really easy. I did not add any extra salt or pepper so my daughter could eat it and we still found it to be very flavorful. This will be added to our favorite meals list!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       10/11/2009   This dish is far too bland for me. I will not make it again. For those making the stew in a slow cooker: you do not need the 3 cups of water required in the oven version. The ingredients generate enough liquid by themselves.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       03/29/2009   I've picked up this recipe because I tried the black bean chili from this month's Everyday Food and it was fabulous. I am a believer in the "hard way." graupma, but beef browned with flour often turns out tough after long cooking; the chili was amazing and took only 15 minutes to throw into the slow cooker. However, I'm still cooking the stew. I added 1 cup of water and it's got a LOT of liquid on it now. The meat is kind of boiled. So, we'll see.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       03/28/2009   The Slow Cooker Variation doesn't have the 3 cups water listed as in the oven method. Does anyone know for sure if the amount of water would be the same for a slow cooker? Thanks!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/23/2009   lovely you probably had it on low so it needed longer to cook. 8 hours on low  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/23/2009   I made this in my dutch oven and it was yummy. I used 1 small can of beef broth to substutute 1 cup of water and I only used 2 tbsps of the vinegar.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/22/2009   A slow cooker is just that, its primarily used for all day cooking like when you wish to put something on before you leave the house and want to return to a cooked meal. A slow cooker won't allow steam to escape,, so yes it might be a bit more liquid. Cut back on the water, if its too thick at the end, add some water or broth. As the recipe says: cook until meat if fork tender... your slow cooker might just need longer  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/19/2009   I'm a total novice at slow cooking. Could someone please tell me if I am supposed to add water to this recipe? I followed the recipe exactly and after 4 hours the beef was not cooked, and the potatoes were warm but raw. We then added water to the slow cooker and after 2 more hours it seemed like a stew. Was the "Add water" bit supposed to be implicit?  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/18/2009   I love the carrots.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/11/2009   Yummy and makes the house smell good. I made the oven recipe. I did not have tomato paste on hand, so I used tomato sauce. I only used 1 Tablespoon of balsamic vinegar. I added one can of french onion soup and the rest water to make the 3 cups water.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/11/2009   I have made the oven version several times and it is definitly a family favorite. Yesterday I made the slow cooker version for the first time. I really did not like the slow cooker version. I'll make this again but only the oven version.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/09/2009   I used a bottom round roast because it was on sale. I didn't have tomato paste, so I used catsup. I used 2 cups of water and one cup of bee stock. Very easy and very delicious. The recipe made a nice, thick gravy.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/05/2009   I added vegetable stock instead of water for more flavor, and I also added white beans and it was great!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/05/2009   I am pretty sure that the 3 cups liquid are also included in the slow cooker version.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/05/2009   The Slow Cooker Variation doesn't have the 3 cups water listed as in the oven method. Does anyone know if the amount of water would be the same for a slow cooker?  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/04/2009   I'm trying mine with Yukon Rose potatoes. I also substituted the vinegar for red wine, we'll see how it turns out, but it sure smells good/.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/04/2009   Twizz1ler--I am not a nutritionist, but I suggest subbing sweet potatoes (or yams, depending on your part of the world), parsnips, and/or turnips for the white potatoes you are avoiding. Likely there are lots of root veggies you'll find to replace the white potatoes. Also, try using cauliflower. Good luck with dinner tonight.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/04/2009   Try Martha's Cornbread Puddings with this stew. I do not have a mini muffin pan, so , I doubled the recipe and made 18 regular pudding muffins. Store leftovers in a freezer bag. Reheat them in a 425 degree oven only until thawed and hot, usually about 10-15 minutes. Came out very moist and delicious. When I cooked the batch from scratch, I used the same oven temp and cooking time. The butter in the cups browns the bottoms and sides.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/04/2009   This recipe is delicious! I cooked mine in the crockpot and I made a few tweaks. First, I browned the beef chuck before adding it to the crockpot. I added a small can of tomato paste rather than the 1/3 c. I didn't use onion, I used a few shallots instead. I was worried that it would be far too rich with the tomato paste and the 3 tbs. of balsamic vinegar, so I also added approx. 1/3 c. of water. It tasted fantasic! This recipe is a winner.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/04/2009   Going to try this tonite - trying to stay away from a lot of white potatoes - what do you think would be good to add?  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/04/2009   The balsamic vinegar would act as a meat tenderizer, and after the length of cooking time, the balsamic flavour would add the "depth" to the stew. You honestly won't even taste the vinegar!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/04/2009   I think that it would be very helpful if the recipes posted here contained the nutrutional values. Why isn't that done?  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/04/2009   i don't think i would like vinegar in this recipe what could i substitute"?  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       02/04/2009   Never waste tomato paste again. Use what is needed, and place the remainder in tablespoonfuls on plastic wrap and freeze it.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/20/2009   I followed the recipe exactly with a crock pot on high for 5 hours and found the meat to be terribly overdone. Next time I will check it after 4 hours and see how that works. On the upside the broth was so delicious and there was plenty of it. In the last 15 minutes I threw in a box of frozen peas which also worked nicely.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/19/2009   This took no time at all to make and was great. I used the crock pot and was worried about not having enough liquid, but it turned out fine. I used sweet potatoes instead of new potatoes and they were very good.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/14/2009   This stew works perfectly in the crock pot. Of course adding broth will make it too thin which is why it is not called for in the recipe. A hearty stew is different than soup..more fork fare with a piece of fresh baked bread to soak up the goodness. If you use a high quality vinegar 3 Tbs is brightens up the flavors and adds a hint of sweetness.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/12/2009   This was a disaster. I used the oven method. Pot was tightly sealed. I reduced the Balsamic Vinegar to 2 tablespoons. All the liquid evaporated. All ingredients turned to mush and had a very strong taste of the vinegar. I was planning to serve this to company but had to throw it out.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       01/08/2009   I used the oven method. So easy and delicious. The balsamic vinegar gives the stew a nice flavor, but I'm glad that I reduced it to 2 1/2 tablespoons. Any more would have been too much for our taste.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       12/04/2008   I made this in a slow cooker. I was concerned about the lack of liquid in the slow cooker version. I followed the recipe exactly, and the consistancy turned out fine after a good stir prior to serving (It was thick, like I prefer). My potatoes were a bit larger, so I had to cut them, and some of the exposed cut sides did turn dark since they were not in liquid. Overall, it was a good recipe; however, it had a little too much of the balsamic vinegar flavor for my family.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/22/2008   What - no water in the slow cooker version?  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/16/2008   I also use a slow cooker. I was a little worried about having no water added but was surprised to see how much gravy there was after 5 hours. It was a little thick so I added a little water towards the end. Taste REALLY good! Will make this for my next potluck!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/13/2008   I like the slow cooker method. I add just a bit more water and it's perfect. My whole family LOVES when I make this. It's definitely worth a try!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/10/2008   The easiest recipe I have ever done! The only thing that I would recommend is to use a 5.5 qt-6 qt slow cooker. I used a 5 qt and ran out of room for everything that I wanted to add. Otherwise, there is no better, cold weather, easy to prepare, great for entertaining, make it with your kids meal!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/10/2008   This stew was delicious and easy! I added parsnips and celery root and it was fantastic - actually ran out of room for potatoes. So I roasted the potatoes and served them on the side. Super easy. I served it to a dinner party on a rainy day and it was perfect! This will be a winter staple!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       11/04/2008   This is such a delicious and easy recipe, no matter how you prepare it. It was definitely a crowd pleaser and will become one of my go-to recipes.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       10/27/2008   I made this on a Sunday Night for my Family and just loved it!! t is so easy to make, and has ample room to add your own flare. I roasted some marrow bones first for 1.5 hours then added them for ultra rich broth later on. just simmed most of the fat off top before serving. I also added sliced parsnips as well. Next time I want to try it with celery root. What flavour!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       10/22/2008   I like my beef stew a little more soupy, and I didn't want to waste any tomato paste so I used the entire can, added a little more balsamic vinegar (use one that is well aged) as well as a can of organic diced tomatoes. The stew turned out rich and delicious. I usually like to sear the flavor of the beef by browning it first, but I tried it the way the recipe instructed, and it turned out great.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       06/09/2008   This is the best beef stew I have made. I used the slow cooker and did not add any liquid, I think that is what made it so wonderful. If I added anything it would be a concentrated liquid, more balsamic vinegar or red wine.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       05/20/2008   To Septemberish - The slow cooker makes its own juice by condensation . Enjoy Greece  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       04/30/2008   I'm wondering why there is no liquid for the slow cooker version too!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       04/09/2008   Great stew. I would suggest using beef broth instead of water...and, of course, we all have our favourite personal touches like parsley for colour or a touch of sage instead of bay leaves - whatever your special ingredients are, this is a perfect beef stew to use as a base.  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       03/25/2008   I marinated the meat in red wine and then used it as the liquid. Fabulous!!  
  
  Martha Stewart Member     Rating: Unrated       03/22/2008   Has anyone found out why there is no liquid (i.e. water or broth) in the slow cooker recipe version? Thanks.  
  

  Martha Stewart Member

  Rating: 5.0 stars 12/26/2019

Thank you for cutting an onion properly in the video. I hate when I see an onion being prepped incorrectly. There is no reason for vertical cuts into an onion before chopping. If you cut an onion in half from stem to root, the onion does the work for you. You just need to make the horizontal cuts on the outside and then chop away.

Rating: 5.0 stars

Rating: 5 stars 11/03/2019

I love this recipe! I think it’s because of the vinegar, the meat is nice and tender.

Rating: 5 stars

Rating: 5 stars 10/06/2019

I/we really enjoyed this. For just 2 of us, 2 lbs of the beef chuck worked out fine. And I also added 2 celery stalks - cut in the 1-1/2" length too. I thought I had an onion, but it was good without it. I normally would have cooked a stew on the stove top. I followed the recipe here and brought it to a boil and then into the oven. I think this really made a difference for me. The meat was incredibly tender. What I would do next time…“up” the tomato paste/balsamic vinegar/flour mixture by about 1/3, and then add another cup of water. Why? We’d like more gravy! It’s a keeper!

Rating: 5 stars 06/26/2019

So I don’t have a slow cooker and big shock confession, I’m a vegan. But I followed the ingredients replacing beef with vegan beef pieces from gardein. I cut the veggies and sautéed them in oil in a pot while I cooked the vegan beef and then added it to the softened veggies with 3 cups of vegan beef stock. Once boiled I lowered the heat and let it simmer for an hour. I also add about 6 stalks of celery chopped and it is so delicious.

Rating: 1 stars 02/28/2019

This was not good for us. Me, my wife, 3 kids and our Au Pair couldn’t make it through a serving. Everybody just kind of pushed it around in their bowls. I made it in the slow cooker and followed the recipe. The balsamic vinegar gave it a sharp bitter taste that did not meld will with the bay leaf and tomato paste. The dish was lacking in flavor and depth and the flavor that it did have was described to me as acrid and bitter. Ours did not thicken and was watery. Didn’t look at all like the video. 6 hours in a slow cooker on high and I still had to put it in the IP to finish it. Won’t be doing this one again.

Rating: 1 stars

Rating: 5 stars 01/27/2019

I made this beef stew recipe yesterday in my crock pot and it was absolutely delicious. I followed the recipe exactly as suggested and didn’t change anything. I have tried many other beef stew recipes in the past and none of them were as delicious as this one. It was easy to prepare and it is a recipe that I will share with my family and friends. Thank you very much for such an easy and delicious recipe for beef stew!

Rating: 5 stars 11/13/2018

LOVED IT! The only alteration made was 3 cups of organic beef broth instead of the water and little potatoes the size of golf balls instead of cut potatoes. And, it only took 2 hours in the oven with my Le Creuset. My guests raved on and on of the taste and beauty of the stew. Thank you for posting such a grand recipe.

Rating: Unrated 10/01/2014

I’ve been using this beef stew recipe for a few years now and I love it! I make it in the crock pot. The only thing I change is that I add additional flour to the beef in the beginning as I like my beef stew thick. I also add a can of beef broth or french onion soup. It comes out perfect every time.

Rating: Unrated

Rating: Unrated 03/07/2014

I make this frequently in the slow cooker, but take the extra time to brown my beef in a skillet and deglaze the pan with some red wine before I assemble the ingredients per the recipe’s instructions. I also add celery and extra garlic cloves/potatoes/carrots, just because of personal preference. It always turns out extremely well. It’s so easy, even with the extra step, and gives a huge flavor payoff. I have never tried the dutch oven version because I don’t have the best oven (renter).

Rating: Unrated 02/17/2014

I’ve been making this recipe for years. It’s in constant rotation for my winter recipes. It’s simple and delicious. I’ve made it in both a crockpot and dutch oven and prefer the dutch oven method.

Rating: Unrated 01/30/2014

Great spring board recipe! The balsamic vinegar definitely gives this stew a tasty kick. I do this in the oven vs. crock pock and instead of adding water, I bump it up and add 2 cups of beef stock and 1 cup of red wine. After 2 hours I throw in a package of quartered baby bella mushrooms and a few handfuls of fresh string beans, trimmed and cut into 1 inch pieces. You can also throw in a handful of frozen peas at the end as well. One dish wonder and oh so good.

Rating: Unrated 01/04/2014

As a relatively new “cook”, I try to follow the recipes to a T but I read the review beforehand for an overall impression. I have never used a slow cooker before but it worked very well. No water was needed and there was plenty of moisture created by the ingredients themselves. I felt that the amount of carrots and onions were heavy. This dish was tasty immediately afterwards; however, re-heated, it lacked its original flavor and texture. A keeper but not on a regular rotation.

Rating: 5 stars 12/20/2013

This recipe is perfect , easy , delicious and exactly what I was looking for .

Rating: 3 stars 11/26/2013

Very very simple and tasty without going to much trouble. I made this in the crock pot using a little over 1 and 1/2 lbs lean stew beef, halved the potatoes and carrots, substituted 8 oz frozen pearl onions for chopped, and added 8 oz sliced cremini mushrooms. Also added some celery seed and dried basil and oregano. Cooked on high for 5 hours. Will probably add a little red wine next time because I would like more gravy. A little crumbled bacon would probably be a nice touch, too.

Rating: 3 stars

Rating: Unrated 10/23/2013

The slow cooker recipe doesn’t say anything about adding water??? I just added it anyway and started it. Sure hope it’s right!

Rating: Unrated 10/04/2013

Remove bay leaf? My grandmother always said “whoever gets the bay leaf has to kiss the cook”.

Rating: 4 stars 09/22/2013

I was looking for a recipe just like this one. Foolproof, tasty and so simple that it wouldn’t take ages to make. Never mind browning meat and wasting time - just mix the first group of ingredients together over medium heat, add the rest of it and plunk it in the oven. That’s it! SO delicious and absolutely tastes like you spent HOURS making it! Will absolutely be making again!

Rating: 4 stars

Rating: Unrated 09/15/2013

Cooked a pound of bacon first, browned meat in bacon fat. Then sauteed mushrooms in fat and de-glazed pot with a can of beef stock. Then added onions, potaotes, 3 tblsp soy sauce, 1 tblsp anchovy paste and a bottle of Cabernet. Put in oven at 300 for 4 hours. YOWZA! So beefy and delicious. Super easy. Took about 30 min to get it into the oven.

Rating: Unrated 07/05/2013

Thanks! When the weather gets cooler I will be making this beef stew. Thanks for posting! Looks like an easy to make recipe.

Rating: 2 stars 04/26/2013

In spite of alll of the ingredients cooking up perfectly. the meat was tender, the carrots and potatoes were perfect, this dish was just ok to me, but my husband liked it. I shared with a friend and she said that although it had some kick to it she still liked it. I thought it was too salty and just not colorful enough. The flavors didn’t excite me. My list of what I didn’t like about this dish is too long so I’ll just say I won’t be making it again. To be fair – I just don’t think I like beef stew.

Rating: 2 stars

Rating: Unrated 03/27/2013

What makes this recipe great is its simplicity. Yeah, there are some better recipes out there, but its hard to beat this one on time and ingredient count. Brown the meat in bacon grease and add the cooked bacon for additional flavor. I recommend a thick cut maple smoked bacon for it because you can taste the difference in the end product. I used a slow cooker and found after several runs that the low setting is better than high. Fridge overnight for best results and reheat prior to eating.

Rating: Unrated 03/18/2013

Made this last night for the first - it was delicious and easy! I’m not generally a huge fan of stew, but boy this hit the spot on a cold night! I cooked in the oven for slightly over 2 hours and the meat and veggies were was tender but not mushy or overcooked in the least. I just served w/ hearty sliced bread. Perfect winter meal!

Rating: Unrated 02/13/2013

I also used my Le Creuset 7 qt pot in the oven at 2.5 hrs. It works perfectly and I prefer it over the slow cooker for retention of color and vitamins in the veg.

over 25 years making stew, and this is the simplest and most delicious result I have ever had!!! A few tweaks to personalize what my family likes- I use one cup beef stock in place of one of the cups of water. I use roasted garlic instead of raw, I use 1Tbs of fresh chopped Rosemary and 1 Tbs fresh Thyme leaves from my garden. I add one leek chopped (light green and white parts) in place of one of the onions. I use 1 Tbs. of Maple Balsamic Vinegar in place of one of the Tbs. of Balsamic. A+ EASY

Rating: Unrated 02/08/2013

I did the low & slow (8hrs) in a slow cooker, and when I first took it out and tasted it, I really didn’t like it. It tasted too much like vinegar and had no depth. I was making it for someone else the next day, so I put it in the fridge thinking I would try and “fix” it in the morning. The next day when I tasted it, it was fabulous! So, my advice is to let it sit a few hours or overnight to let the flavors meld. I dd the recipe as stated with the addition of 1/3 c beef broth. Really good!

Rating: Unrated 01/03/2013

Made this today (oven version). Husband and I loved it. Easy peasy, absolute perfection.

Rating: Unrated 12/27/2012

Made this the other night for the first time using the crockpot. Would have been excellent had I known to add 3 cups of water. The ingredient list or crockpot variation instructions so not say anything about water, which made my stew very very dry. Will definitley make this again, next time using water or beef stock and I know it will be delicious! They should really update this.

Rating: Unrated 12/05/2012

Made the stew last night in our crock pot, and it turned out wonderfully, with one addition– I added a cup of a nice red wine and let it simmer away for about the last hour of cooking; added a nice depth to the flavor, and complimented the vinegar nicely. Have to say, this stew was a wonderful end to a rainy day.

Rating: Unrated 11/19/2012

A bit sweet. I didn’t care for the tomato taste.

Rating: Unrated 11/18/2012

My family and I loved this dish. I made it in the oven instead of a slow cooker just so I could cut cooking time. The meal was super easy to make and an easy clean up! It’s very hearty and filling and serves 8 easily. Just bought a fresh loaf to go along with it. I’ll be sure to make this meal time and time again.

Rating: Unrated 09/26/2012

We absolutely loved this recipe! I did the slow cooker version & it was literally dump it all in there & forget about it! We have a very tight schedule on Wednesdays so I think this will definitely be going into my rotation. It was meaty-and the meat was soooooooo tender!-, it had a good serving of veggies in it. It was extremely flavorful, I seasoned the beef with seasoned salt before I put it in though, I will say I enjoy natural flavors over anyway. I served it with pretzel rolls!

Rating: 5 stars 03/31/2012

I used the Slow Cooker method of preparation at a low temperature for 8 hours and can assure confused readers that it is NOT necessary to add the 3 cups of water required for the stove-top/oven method: the ingredients provide their own liquid as the stew cooks. Otherwise, the only further comment I can make is that this is unquestionably the best beef stew I have ever prepared and recommend this recipe heartily without qualifications or additional suggestions.

Rating: Unrated 01/26/2012

Looks good. I usually add my potatoes and carrots after beef cooks 2 hours and cook the vegetables for 30 minutes. That way the vegetables aren’t mushy.

Rating: Unrated 12/10/2011

I’ve tried this recipe on the stove and in the slow cooker. I definitely favored the slow cooker results. The meat came out a LOT more tender that way. I really jam pack the ingredients in because I’m usually feeding a crowd (plus this recipe reheats VERY well!) I found that the stove version of this stew made for less tender meat and mooshy veggies. I’d almost always suggest going for the crockpot version and using just a little liquid (either a cup of water or beef stock) Yum! A favorite!

Rating: Unrated 11/16/2011

i made this tonight in the crock pot for the first time and it was great! i think next time the carrots need to be cut in half because they were hard to keep on the fork. i didnt tell my husband that there was vinegar in it bc i knew he wouldnt be as open to trying it. he loved it and we both agreed that this was the best stew ive made yet. i didnt grow up liking stew so im slowly learning how to. i even ate leftovers which i never do! this is going into our favorites pile!!

also at the end of cooking, i took out about a 1/2C of the liquid and whisked in about 4 TB of flour. my husband likes his stew liquid a little thicker than what it originally came out as. then i added that to the stew and let it sit for about 10 minutes so the flour flavor could cook out. that made it the perfect consistancy for us!

Rating: Unrated 11/07/2011

Made it in the slow cooker for the first time tonight. It was a success. The meat was tender and vegetables were excellent. I added celery as an extra. In order to jazz it up a bit, next time we will add more seasoning. It looked just like the picture!

Rating: 2 stars 06/11/2011

This recipe just did not work for me. It was bland, tasteless. I will give it 5 starts however, in part, because the meat was just about the most perfect I’ve ever had out of a slow cooker.

Rating: Unrated 03/03/2011

I made this the other night and it was very good and extremely easy. Next time I might change it from 3tbl of vinegar to 2 because the flavor was kind of strong. I’d also check on it about half way through and give it a stir because mine started to dry out on top a little. (I did the baked version) I added some peas at the end. Yum!

Rating: Unrated 02/01/2011

This was amazing! I made it on the stove top and instead of water, I used beef broth. Next time I’ll use orange juice instead of balsamic vinegar for a different twist. Yummm!

Rating: Unrated 01/05/2011

Also, I forgot to mention in my previous comment, I cooked mine with a whole Axis rump roast instead of cubes!

Delicious!!!!! Cooked mine in a 7 qt. crockpot with loose lid and draped a towel over it, it came out perfect! But be sure to turn the heat down to low the last couple of hours cause I didn’t and had to add 2 cups more water at serving time, but it was still YUMMY!!!

Rating: Unrated 01/02/2011

Loved this. I was nervous because I have a 7 qt. Crock pot with not the tightest-fitting lid. No need to worry… turned out great!

Rating: Unrated 11/20/2010

susansmeke: Thanks for you response! My dinner turned out quite yummy…I ended up giving it a stir because I had read that someone suggested adding peas in the last 15 minutes of cooking so I added them and gave it a stir. I let it cook for about 30 minutes longer after this. I think stirring helped to mix it all up too and really get the flavors into the veggies. I didn’t add the water and it turned out fine. There was enough moisture that had seeped out from the ingredients :)

Rating: Unrated 11/13/2010

I made this and it came out perfect. My oven tends to run a little hot, so I cooked it at 325. I added celery to add a little sweetness to it (my fam likes red onions, but I only had white so tried to compensate a little bit). Meat was tender and veggies were perfect. Thanks for a simple, great recipe!

Rating: Unrated 11/10/2010

OregonWinoFoodie: You are right, use a dutch oven and start it on the stovetop. When it comes to a boil transfer the pot to the oven. A dutch oven is designed for both stovetop and oven cooking and should have a tight fitting lid (one that wan’t let all the juice escape in the form of steam.) Hopefully you have an enameled cast iron dutch oven - they’re great and you don’t have to spend $$$$. Martha Stewart has a nice one available at Macy’s at a good price.

PS lilwbprincess: I don’t know why the slow cooker version doesn’t say to add the water, but hopefully you read the oven version and saw that you needed to add 3 cups of water. Hope your dinner was delicious!

lilwbprincess: You shouldn’t have to stir this. A well written recipe should tell you just the order to put things into the pot and if it is necessary to stir half way through cooking. It rarley is necessary or suggested to stir during the cooking process in a slow cooker, because removing the lid lets a lot of heat escape and then it has to come back up to temperature. Then it is REALLY sloooww coooking;) The order of ingredients is calculated for even cooking, so important to follow.

Rating: Unrated 11/04/2010

For crockpot: do you stir the stew at all? Before turning on the pot? Halfway through? I’m a very beginner cook and I just have no clue about this stuff…I’m concerned that the meat will just cook and burn as the bottom layer and all the veggies sitting on top will dry out. I would appreciate any help anyone has :) (I actually just started it about 10 minutes ago, but I’d love to know if I’m supposed to mix everything for next time)

Rating: Unrated 10/31/2010

I’m confused about the oven version… It says to bring the dish to a boil and then transfer to the oven. So I’m assuming you bring the stew to a boil on the stove and then transfer to the oven? I seem to be the only one confused about that!

Rating: Unrated 10/19/2010

So easy and very tasty. I did the slow-cooker variation, on high for 5 hours. The meat came out extremely tender, but the bottom layer was a little burnt. Not sure if it was the high temp, or if my crock pot is just crummy. Regardless, this is a great, simple recipe that I’ll definitely make again.

Rating: Unrated 10/10/2010

Great recipe. I added celery and cut back the pepper. Brought the pot to a boil before sliding it into the thermos for 10 hours. Meat came out melt-in-your mouth soft. Veggies were perfect.

Rating: Unrated 05/24/2010

I made this beef stew last night and we had it for dinner today. It was so good, the best beef stew i ever ate. I cooked it in the dutch over. The vegetables and meet just melt in your mouth. Thank you for the great recipe!!!

Rating: Unrated 05/19/2010

I think this is terrific recipe. I do the dutch oven version and it consistently comes out great. It has a thick, hearty texture. You definitely need to be generous with the salt and pepper to bring out the flavor in the beef. It’s super easy though and perfect if you want a hearty meal on a rainy or cold day.

Rating: Unrated 11/03/2009

My husband, 1-year old daughter and I all loved this recipe. I made the slow-cooker version and halved the recipe. It was really, really easy. I did not add any extra salt or pepper so my daughter could eat it and we still found it to be very flavorful. This will be added to our favorite meals list!

Rating: Unrated 10/11/2009

This dish is far too bland for me. I will not make it again. For those making the stew in a slow cooker: you do not need the 3 cups of water required in the oven version. The ingredients generate enough liquid by themselves.

Rating: Unrated 03/29/2009

I’ve picked up this recipe because I tried the black bean chili from this month’s Everyday Food and it was fabulous. I am a believer in the “hard way.” graupma, but beef browned with flour often turns out tough after long cooking; the chili was amazing and took only 15 minutes to throw into the slow cooker. However, I’m still cooking the stew. I added 1 cup of water and it’s got a LOT of liquid on it now. The meat is kind of boiled. So, we’ll see.

Rating: Unrated 03/28/2009

The Slow Cooker Variation doesn’t have the 3 cups water listed as in the oven method. Does anyone know for sure if the amount of water would be the same for a slow cooker? Thanks!

Rating: Unrated 02/23/2009

lovely you probably had it on low so it needed longer to cook. 8 hours on low

I made this in my dutch oven and it was yummy. I used 1 small can of beef broth to substutute 1 cup of water and I only used 2 tbsps of the vinegar.

Rating: Unrated 02/22/2009

A slow cooker is just that, its primarily used for all day cooking like when you wish to put something on before you leave the house and want to return to a cooked meal. A slow cooker won’t allow steam to escape,, so yes it might be a bit more liquid. Cut back on the water, if its too thick at the end, add some water or broth. As the recipe says: cook until meat if fork tender… your slow cooker might just need longer

Rating: Unrated 02/19/2009

I’m a total novice at slow cooking. Could someone please tell me if I am supposed to add water to this recipe? I followed the recipe exactly and after 4 hours the beef was not cooked, and the potatoes were warm but raw. We then added water to the slow cooker and after 2 more hours it seemed like a stew. Was the “Add water” bit supposed to be implicit?

Rating: Unrated 02/18/2009

I love the carrots.

Rating: Unrated 02/11/2009

Yummy and makes the house smell good. I made the oven recipe. I did not have tomato paste on hand, so I used tomato sauce. I only used 1 Tablespoon of balsamic vinegar. I added one can of french onion soup and the rest water to make the 3 cups water.

I have made the oven version several times and it is definitly a family favorite. Yesterday I made the slow cooker version for the first time. I really did not like the slow cooker version. I’ll make this again but only the oven version.

Rating: Unrated 02/09/2009

I used a bottom round roast because it was on sale. I didn’t have tomato paste, so I used catsup. I used 2 cups of water and one cup of bee stock. Very easy and very delicious. The recipe made a nice, thick gravy.

Rating: Unrated 02/05/2009

I added vegetable stock instead of water for more flavor, and I also added white beans and it was great!

I am pretty sure that the 3 cups liquid are also included in the slow cooker version.

The Slow Cooker Variation doesn’t have the 3 cups water listed as in the oven method. Does anyone know if the amount of water would be the same for a slow cooker?

Rating: Unrated 02/04/2009

I’m trying mine with Yukon Rose potatoes. I also substituted the vinegar for red wine, we’ll see how it turns out, but it sure smells good/.

Twizz1ler–I am not a nutritionist, but I suggest subbing sweet potatoes (or yams, depending on your part of the world), parsnips, and/or turnips for the white potatoes you are avoiding. Likely there are lots of root veggies you’ll find to replace the white potatoes. Also, try using cauliflower. Good luck with dinner tonight.

Try Martha’s Cornbread Puddings with this stew. I do not have a mini muffin pan, so , I doubled the recipe and made 18 regular pudding muffins. Store leftovers in a freezer bag. Reheat them in a 425 degree oven only until thawed and hot, usually about 10-15 minutes. Came out very moist and delicious. When I cooked the batch from scratch, I used the same oven temp and cooking time. The butter in the cups browns the bottoms and sides.

This recipe is delicious! I cooked mine in the crockpot and I made a few tweaks. First, I browned the beef chuck before adding it to the crockpot. I added a small can of tomato paste rather than the 1/3 c. I didn’t use onion, I used a few shallots instead. I was worried that it would be far too rich with the tomato paste and the 3 tbs. of balsamic vinegar, so I also added approx. 1/3 c. of water. It tasted fantasic! This recipe is a winner.

Going to try this tonite - trying to stay away from a lot of white potatoes - what do you think would be good to add?

The balsamic vinegar would act as a meat tenderizer, and after the length of cooking time, the balsamic flavour would add the “depth” to the stew. You honestly won’t even taste the vinegar!

I think that it would be very helpful if the recipes posted here contained the nutrutional values. Why isn’t that done?

i don’t think i would like vinegar in this recipe what could i substitute"?

Never waste tomato paste again. Use what is needed, and place the remainder in tablespoonfuls on plastic wrap and freeze it.

Rating: Unrated 01/20/2009

I followed the recipe exactly with a crock pot on high for 5 hours and found the meat to be terribly overdone. Next time I will check it after 4 hours and see how that works. On the upside the broth was so delicious and there was plenty of it. In the last 15 minutes I threw in a box of frozen peas which also worked nicely.

Rating: Unrated 01/19/2009

This took no time at all to make and was great. I used the crock pot and was worried about not having enough liquid, but it turned out fine. I used sweet potatoes instead of new potatoes and they were very good.

Rating: Unrated 01/14/2009

This stew works perfectly in the crock pot. Of course adding broth will make it too thin which is why it is not called for in the recipe. A hearty stew is different than soup..more fork fare with a piece of fresh baked bread to soak up the goodness. If you use a high quality vinegar 3 Tbs is brightens up the flavors and adds a hint of sweetness.

Rating: Unrated 01/12/2009

This was a disaster. I used the oven method. Pot was tightly sealed. I reduced the Balsamic Vinegar to 2 tablespoons. All the liquid evaporated. All ingredients turned to mush and had a very strong taste of the vinegar. I was planning to serve this to company but had to throw it out.

Rating: Unrated 01/08/2009

I used the oven method. So easy and delicious. The balsamic vinegar gives the stew a nice flavor, but I’m glad that I reduced it to 2 1/2 tablespoons. Any more would have been too much for our taste.

Rating: Unrated 12/04/2008

I made this in a slow cooker. I was concerned about the lack of liquid in the slow cooker version. I followed the recipe exactly, and the consistancy turned out fine after a good stir prior to serving (It was thick, like I prefer). My potatoes were a bit larger, so I had to cut them, and some of the exposed cut sides did turn dark since they were not in liquid. Overall, it was a good recipe; however, it had a little too much of the balsamic vinegar flavor for my family.

Rating: Unrated 11/22/2008

What - no water in the slow cooker version?

Rating: Unrated 11/16/2008

I also use a slow cooker. I was a little worried about having no water added but was surprised to see how much gravy there was after 5 hours. It was a little thick so I added a little water towards the end. Taste REALLY good! Will make this for my next potluck!

Rating: Unrated 11/13/2008

I like the slow cooker method. I add just a bit more water and it’s perfect. My whole family LOVES when I make this. It’s definitely worth a try!

Rating: Unrated 11/10/2008

The easiest recipe I have ever done! The only thing that I would recommend is to use a 5.5 qt-6 qt slow cooker. I used a 5 qt and ran out of room for everything that I wanted to add. Otherwise, there is no better, cold weather, easy to prepare, great for entertaining, make it with your kids meal!

This stew was delicious and easy! I added parsnips and celery root and it was fantastic - actually ran out of room for potatoes. So I roasted the potatoes and served them on the side. Super easy. I served it to a dinner party on a rainy day and it was perfect! This will be a winter staple!

Rating: Unrated 11/04/2008

This is such a delicious and easy recipe, no matter how you prepare it. It was definitely a crowd pleaser and will become one of my go-to recipes.

Rating: Unrated 10/27/2008

I made this on a Sunday Night for my Family and just loved it!! t is so easy to make, and has ample room to add your own flare. I roasted some marrow bones first for 1.5 hours then added them for ultra rich broth later on. just simmed most of the fat off top before serving. I also added sliced parsnips as well. Next time I want to try it with celery root. What flavour!

Rating: Unrated 10/22/2008

I like my beef stew a little more soupy, and I didn’t want to waste any tomato paste so I used the entire can, added a little more balsamic vinegar (use one that is well aged) as well as a can of organic diced tomatoes. The stew turned out rich and delicious. I usually like to sear the flavor of the beef by browning it first, but I tried it the way the recipe instructed, and it turned out great.

Rating: Unrated 06/09/2008

This is the best beef stew I have made. I used the slow cooker and did not add any liquid, I think that is what made it so wonderful. If I added anything it would be a concentrated liquid, more balsamic vinegar or red wine.

Rating: Unrated 05/20/2008

To Septemberish - The slow cooker makes its own juice by condensation . Enjoy Greece

Rating: Unrated 04/30/2008

I’m wondering why there is no liquid for the slow cooker version too!

Rating: Unrated 04/09/2008

Great stew. I would suggest using beef broth instead of water…and, of course, we all have our favourite personal touches like parsley for colour or a touch of sage instead of bay leaves - whatever your special ingredients are, this is a perfect beef stew to use as a base.

Rating: Unrated 03/25/2008

I marinated the meat in red wine and then used it as the liquid. Fabulous!!

Rating: Unrated 03/22/2008

Has anyone found out why there is no liquid (i.e. water or broth) in the slow cooker recipe version? Thanks.

All Reviews for Beef Stew

• of Reviews Reviews: Most Helpful Most Helpful Most Positive Least Positive Newest

All Reviews for Beef Stew

• of Reviews

  Reviews: Most Helpful Most Helpful Most Positive Least Positive Newest

Reviews: Most Helpful

Most Helpful     Most Positive     Least Positive     Newest