Yellow Butter Cake Recipe

Back to Yellow Butter Cake

All Reviews for Yellow Butter Cake

of Reviews

Reviews:

Most Helpful

Most Positive

Least Positive

Newest

Gallery

Read the full recipe after the video.

Recipe Summary

Yield: Makes two 9-inch cake layers

vanilla pecan sand castle

Ingredients

Ingredient Checklist

2 sticks (1 cup) unsalted butter, room temperature, plus more for pans

1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour, plus more for pans

1 1/2 cups cake flour (not self-rising)

1 tablespoon baking powder

1/2 teaspoon salt

1 3/4 cups sugar

4 large eggs

2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract

1 1/4 cups milk

Gallery

Read the full recipe after the video.

Recipe Summary

Yield: Makes two 9-inch cake layers

vanilla pecan sand castle

Gallery

Read the full recipe after the video.

Recipe Summary

Yield: Makes two 9-inch cake layers

Recipe Summary

Yield: Makes two 9-inch cake layers

Makes two 9-inch cake layers

vanilla pecan sand castle

Ingredients

2 sticks (1 cup) unsalted butter, room temperature, plus more for pans
1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour, plus more for pans
1 1/2 cups cake flour (not self-rising)
1 tablespoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 3/4 cups sugar
4 large eggs
2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract
1 1/4 cups milk

Directions

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Butter two 9-by-2-inch round cake pans; line the bottoms with parchment paper. Butter parchment, and dust with flour, tapping out excess; set aside. Into a medium bowl, sift together flours, baking powder, and salt; set aside.

In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat the butter and sugar until light and fluffy, 3 to 4 minutes, scraping down the sides of the bowl as needed. Beat in eggs, one at a time, then beat in vanilla. With the mixer on low speed, add the flour mixture in 3 parts, alternating with the milk and beginning and ending with the flour; beat until combined after each addition.

Divide batter between the prepared pans, and smooth with an offset spatula. Bake, rotating the pans halfway through, until cakes are golden brown and a cake tester inserted into the center comes out clean, 30 to 35 minutes. Transfer pans to a wire rack to cool 20 minutes. Invert cakes onto the rack; peel off the parchment. Reinvert cakes and let them cool completely, top sides up.

Reviews (50)

Add Rating & Review

1316 Ratings

5 star values:

4 star values:

3 star values:

2 star values:

1 star values:

Load More Reviews

Reviews (50)

Add Rating & Review

1316 Ratings

5 star values:

4 star values:

3 star values:

2 star values:

1 star values:

Add Rating & Review

1316 Ratings

5 star values:

4 star values:

3 star values:

2 star values:

1 star values:

1316 Ratings

5 star values:

4 star values:

3 star values:

2 star values:

1 star values:

1316 Ratings

5 star values:

4 star values:

3 star values:

2 star values:

1 star values:

5 star values:
203
4 star values:
221
3 star values:
515
2 star values:
300
1 star values:
77

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5.0 stars

08/26/2020

                This recipe is just perfect and I have been using it to make my kids’ birthday cakes for years. People always compliment me on it and ask for the recipe. This is a keeper!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

05/26/2018

                This is a good basic yellow cake recipe. Not too sweet. Don't skimp on the quality of the eggs. Nice deep yellow egg yolks is the key to a nice color.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

09/15/2017

                I've made this several times and it turns out perfect every time.  It's not at all dense, not sure what people may be doing wrong, but it's not heavy or dense when I make it following the instructions.  The colour isn't yellow for me, and is more on the white-ish side, but that's likely because of my eggs.  The yolks of my eggs are on the pale side so that likely impacts the colour of the resulting cake.  I use a strawberry buttercream icing from "The Cake Bible" along with sliced fresh strawberries between layers and this result is sinful and oh-so-decadent!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

02/25/2017

                Without a doubt, this cake is moist, dense, and decadently sweet, all in its own; however, when you frost it with a much less-sweet, chocolate Swiss meringue buttercream (using very dark - 85% cacao organic bars - or the like), the combonation is a PERFECT balance!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

07/02/2016

                Made this for a birthday. Frosted it with Borden's fudge frosting. The best, most flavorful yellow cake ever!  This is a keeper!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

10/30/2015

                The cake is wonderful but it's not your typical yellow cake! the texture sort of reminded me of pound cake. and i made this twice but my cake came out white. when i make it again i will add less sugar than the recipe asks, because i felt it was a little too sweet.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

09/03/2015

                Love the butter taste. The cake was quite dense but good either way.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

08/23/2014

                Anybody not too enthused about the heaviness of the cake can easily reduce flour to about 2 1/4 cups and beat the butter and sugar for about 20 minutes.  That will give you a lighter, fluffier batter.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 4 stars

08/15/2014

                Excellent taste but the cake is too dense, it looks pretty fluffy in the pictures but it doesnt turn out like that, and I have done it several times.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 3 stars

04/21/2014

                I made the cake this past weekend and everyone loved it. It was moist and delicious, but personally I was a little disappointed in the texture of the cake. I prefer lighter fluffier layer and they were really pretty dense. More like a pound cake. Martha has always been my go to girl, but I will probably use a different recipe next time.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

02/13/2014

                Made this cake for my hubbies birthday. It was very tasty, smelled delicious and was not dry. I can't say it was extremely moist, but 3 days later (of sitting on the counter on a covered cake stand) the cake is still reasonably moist.
                I followed most of the instructions but I used a quick substitute of Corn starch and AP flour for the cake flour. 
                I frosted this with chocolate frosting and it is delicious. Better than a box, but I am still looking for a recipe with more moisture in the cake.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

11/13/2013

                nice
                San Diego Lasik Surgery

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

11/13/2013

                Thanks a lot for sharing us about this update. 
                Hope you will not get tired on making posts as informative as this
                Lasik surgery in San Diego

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

10/07/2013

                I freaked out when I read the negative reviews because I was gonna bake this for my friends bday. Well, the cake was moist and very delicious. I didn't have many options for flour so I baked with the all purpose flour only. It was scrumptious indeed and will definitely bake that again! It was very easy. I dunno what went wrong with the negative reviews but mine was super good!!!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

09/16/2013

                This recipe is more of a genoise than a yellow cake. I am a pretty experienced baker and followed the recipe, but it did not result in a springy, spongy cake. Instead, we ended up with something resembling a French madeleine, but less dense.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

09/12/2013

                Also forgot to add, you must do the toothpick test on this cake, mine definitely did not look done but tested done. Again turned out beautiful and very moist. I didn't read the reviews until after I baked mine, not really sure why so many said it was dry, because mine was very very moist. I do cream my butter and sugar until it is very light and fluffy and make sure you just mix until everything is combined. Good Luck! God Bless!!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

09/12/2013

                Excellent very moist cake and easy recipe. Didn't change a thing and it was the most moist yellow cake that I have ever made, and I have been searching for years for a really moist yellow cake. Will definitely be my go to yellow cake forever more!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

08/08/2013

                I made this batter for cupcakes, adding natural maraschino cherries, and it was delicious. I followed the recipe, making my own cake flour, and I made sure not to over mix. I don't know how these cupcakes will make it to my son's Birthday party without being eaten. Delicious! I baked the cupcakes for 22 minutes.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

05/14/2013

                Oh I forgot to add to my review what might have made the texture of the cake dry - they could have over mixed their batter.  The trick is to beat all the ingredients but not to over beat them.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

05/14/2013

                I made this cake the other night and it was SCRUMPTIOUS!  I know that a lot of the reviewers say that their cakes were dry, but mine turned out moist and very, very good.  I did however use "Cake Flour" instead of the "All-Purpose" which gave the cake a light and airy texture, but other than that I did exactly as Martha Stewart recipe directed.  Thanks Martha for yet another WONDERFULLY Delicious Recipe:-)

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

04/27/2013

                Can not wait to try this recipe. I like the idea of doing basic cooking. Not alot of planning and work. Plus I don't really know alot of basics. so I really enjoy the classes. Keep them coming.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

08/21/2012

                I made this cake today following the recipe exactly. The cake came out nice. It's light  and fluffy. I like it, but I can understand some people think it's dry. They like really moist cakes. I guess it's all up to your preference. I will make this cake again.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

08/17/2012

                I just took the cake out; it took 30-35 min to bake. It's not a golden brown as my 7 up cakes are; the color is lighter, but I tested it with a toothpick and it's done - glad I did it, because it didn't look like it was done. I'll let you know how it tastes after I add the frosting and eat it, but it looks good.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

07/25/2012

                If you have a problem with dryness consider your cooling method. If possible leave this cake in the pan while cooling and drape a towel over it to prevent it from drying out. Also make sure not to overcook. I love this recipe. It has worked out much better than all the other yellow cake recipes I've found on the internet. If you need the pan immediately find some other method to cover your cake.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 3 stars

06/13/2012

                Did everyone cook it for only 30 min at 350? mine was not cooked at all i had to cook it for almost an hour.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5 stars

06/09/2012

                I love this cake! I bake this cake for almost every occasion, my son's birthday party, etc.. I am really suprised there are so many bad reviews. I have never had a problem with the cake being dry. Everytime I make this cake everyone loves it. Watching foodnetwork and other baking shows I know they say if you over mix the batter it can make the cake dry along with over cooking it so that could be a problem? I always mix the batter just until the ingredients are mixed well and no more. Great cake!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

04/20/2012

                Just made this for the first time for my great nephew's birthday cake.  It is light and fluffy and full of old time, yellow cake taste.  If you follow the recipe as written, I don't know how you could get anything other than a yellow cake to rival any that my grandmother used to make.  It's delicious and easy to make.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

02/05/2012

                The secret is - cream butter and sugar really well - must be light and fluffy, have ALL ingredients at room temp, mix in dry ingredients until JUST incorporated - over-mixing will result in tough/dry cake.  I used 1 C milk and 1/4 C buttermilk, watch closely - do not overbake! It was moist and light - very tasty!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

01/31/2012

                This recipe was a huge disappointment. I tested the cake at 30 min and the center was a bit underdone so I left it in an additional 3 minutes.  Once the tester came out clean I took out of the oven straight away. It was an awful crumbly, dry mess. My time is valuable and I could have done better with a box mix. So, this will not be my go to yellow cake. Shame.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

12/26/2011

                Not exactly a review - a question.  Martha uses a bowl sifter - a terrific idea for a person with awful arthritis. But where can you get one like this, without little knobs and handles to hit your hands when you pat it to sift? thanks!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

10/07/2011

                Great simple recipe.  Using fresh eggs and butter will make the flavor amazing.  Lovely, delicately flavored cake, perfect for a birthday cake!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

09/10/2011

                I  think this is an excellent recipe and I have now idea why so many people found this to be dry.  It's light and moist and holds up well to slicing and filling.  The dryness in a cake is usually as a result of overcooking or cooking at too high a temperature.  I didn't follow the timing in recipes, as i always judge when a cake is ready by sight. I have an oven that runs a little hot; had I left it for 30 minutes, it would have been over-baked.  I can't wait to try the other variations.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

09/05/2011

                I followed the directions exactly and watched the time closely. It came out very dry and very dense. Can't think what could have happened. The flavor was good though. With ice cream piled on it was better. I used recipe from Martha's Baking Handbook which is exactly the same as this one. Wish I had read reviews here first :(

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

09/03/2011

                in reading the reviews, i saw that some people had trouble with this cake being too dry... so i added an additional egg yolk. i also substituted vanilla soymilk for regular milk, just because that's what i had on hand. i turned this into cupcakes (and the recipe basically makes 24 normal size cupcakes perfectly). they came out SO delicious, light and fluffy.  i used a chocolate ganache instead of traditional icing and they are a huuuuge hit.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

07/04/2011

                Made this cake for the holidays and straight from the oven, it was an instant hit! It was delicious, soft and sufficiently moist. This receipe has become a family favorite and will surely be more than a season delight!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

07/01/2011

                Not only dry, but salty! Too much baking powder perhaps?  1 Tbsp seems excessive.  Also, the editor's note at the top of recipe is puzzling:  it suggests increasing the salt to 1 tsp if using 8" pans vs. 1/2 tsp for 9" pans --  doesn't seem logical.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

06/07/2011

                It's too dry.  I checked the cake at 30 mins (low side) and it was done!  Probably too done because it was a little on the dry side.  Comparing it to other recipes, I'm thinking I'll cut down 1/4 c. on the butter and add in 1/4 c. canola oil with the milk and trim 5-7 mins on baking

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

04/27/2011

                I baked this cake today for a dinner party.   It came out a bit on the dry side, even though I was careful to watch the time (and pulled it out a little early just in case).

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

02/27/2011

                This cake is delicious. It is very dense and holds up well for decorating or molding. I did not find it dry. Instead I felt it was a bit too sweet. So, I cut the sugar. It was a complete hit at my son's first birthday party.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

02/23/2011

                did not care for the texture or taste.  VERY DRY.  I  would add some sour cream.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

02/02/2011

                Hi Martha! Can you please give weight measurements in your recipes? Good luck with the new show, I'm hooked already

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

02/01/2011

                I halved this recipe and made 14 cupcakes from the batter. I saw on America's Test Kitchen that they used bread flour when making cupcakes in order to make them a little sturdier for eating out of your hands, so I used AP flour and Bread flour instead of AP flour and Cake flour. They tasted wonderfully and weren't delicate for preschoolers hands. Perfect. I didn't think they were dry at all.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

04/27/2010

                A bit dry... good flavor though... but dry!

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

04/06/2010

                This cake was tasty, but a little dry.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

03/19/2010

                Dear DessertFanatic, I too live at high altitude, if you reduce the baking powder to 2 teaspoons and add 1/4 teaspoon baking soda you should have no problem with the cake sinking and the texture will be improved. Also, if the cake was a little dry you may have overmixed slightly or bake a little to long. I hope this helps.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

03/14/2010

                I tried this cake recipe and it is good.  Moist and buttery tasting.    It didn't blow my socks off but it was still good.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

03/04/2010

                I was pretty disappointed with this recipe.  The crumb wasn't as fine and the texture wasn't as moist and light as I wanted it to be.  Also, if you live at high altitudes, you'll probably need to make some adjustments in the ingredients, because my cakes sunk slightly in the middle.  I just cut off the tops to level them anyway, but I just wanted perfection, and this cake didn't give me that.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

09/05/2009

                This cake is good.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: Unrated

01/17/2009

                Just used a hand mixer and everything turned out fine.  I baked this with my 3 yr old's help.  We used a bundt cake pan instead and topped it with icing and fresh strawberries.  A very sophisticated 3rd bday cake (I must admit) but she loved that she made it herself.

Martha Stewart Member

Rating: 5.0 stars

08/26/2020

                This recipe is just perfect and I have been using it to make my kids’ birthday cakes for years. People always compliment me on it and ask for the recipe. This is a keeper!

Rating: 5.0 stars

Rating: 5 stars

05/26/2018

                This is a good basic yellow cake recipe. Not too sweet. Don't skimp on the quality of the eggs. Nice deep yellow egg yolks is the key to a nice color.

Rating: 5 stars

09/15/2017

                I've made this several times and it turns out perfect every time.  It's not at all dense, not sure what people may be doing wrong, but it's not heavy or dense when I make it following the instructions.  The colour isn't yellow for me, and is more on the white-ish side, but that's likely because of my eggs.  The yolks of my eggs are on the pale side so that likely impacts the colour of the resulting cake.  I use a strawberry buttercream icing from "The Cake Bible" along with sliced fresh strawberries between layers and this result is sinful and oh-so-decadent!

Rating: Unrated

02/25/2017

                Without a doubt, this cake is moist, dense, and decadently sweet, all in its own; however, when you frost it with a much less-sweet, chocolate Swiss meringue buttercream (using very dark - 85% cacao organic bars - or the like), the combonation is a PERFECT balance!

Rating: Unrated

Rating: 5 stars

07/02/2016

                Made this for a birthday. Frosted it with Borden's fudge frosting. The best, most flavorful yellow cake ever!  This is a keeper!

Rating: Unrated

10/30/2015

                The cake is wonderful but it's not your typical yellow cake! the texture sort of reminded me of pound cake. and i made this twice but my cake came out white. when i make it again i will add less sugar than the recipe asks, because i felt it was a little too sweet.

Rating: Unrated

09/03/2015

                Love the butter taste. The cake was quite dense but good either way.

Rating: Unrated

08/23/2014

                Anybody not too enthused about the heaviness of the cake can easily reduce flour to about 2 1/4 cups and beat the butter and sugar for about 20 minutes.  That will give you a lighter, fluffier batter.

Rating: 4 stars

08/15/2014

                Excellent taste but the cake is too dense, it looks pretty fluffy in the pictures but it doesnt turn out like that, and I have done it several times.

Rating: 4 stars

Rating: 3 stars

04/21/2014

                I made the cake this past weekend and everyone loved it. It was moist and delicious, but personally I was a little disappointed in the texture of the cake. I prefer lighter fluffier layer and they were really pretty dense. More like a pound cake. Martha has always been my go to girl, but I will probably use a different recipe next time.

Rating: 3 stars

Rating: Unrated

02/13/2014

                Made this cake for my hubbies birthday. It was very tasty, smelled delicious and was not dry. I can't say it was extremely moist, but 3 days later (of sitting on the counter on a covered cake stand) the cake is still reasonably moist.
                I followed most of the instructions but I used a quick substitute of Corn starch and AP flour for the cake flour. 
                I frosted this with chocolate frosting and it is delicious. Better than a box, but I am still looking for a recipe with more moisture in the cake.

Rating: Unrated

11/13/2013

                nice
                San Diego Lasik Surgery 


                    
                Thanks a lot for sharing us about this update. 
                Hope you will not get tired on making posts as informative as this
                Lasik surgery in San Diego

Rating: Unrated

10/07/2013

                I freaked out when I read the negative reviews because I was gonna bake this for my friends bday. Well, the cake was moist and very delicious. I didn't have many options for flour so I baked with the all purpose flour only. It was scrumptious indeed and will definitely bake that again! It was very easy. I dunno what went wrong with the negative reviews but mine was super good!!!

Rating: Unrated

09/16/2013

                This recipe is more of a genoise than a yellow cake. I am a pretty experienced baker and followed the recipe, but it did not result in a springy, spongy cake. Instead, we ended up with something resembling a French madeleine, but less dense.

Rating: Unrated

09/12/2013

                Also forgot to add, you must do the toothpick test on this cake, mine definitely did not look done but tested done. Again turned out beautiful and very moist. I didn't read the reviews until after I baked mine, not really sure why so many said it was dry, because mine was very very moist. I do cream my butter and sugar until it is very light and fluffy and make sure you just mix until everything is combined. Good Luck! God Bless!!  


                    
                Excellent very moist cake and easy recipe. Didn't change a thing and it was the most moist yellow cake that I have ever made, and I have been searching for years for a really moist yellow cake. Will definitely be my go to yellow cake forever more!

Rating: 5 stars

08/08/2013

                I made this batter for cupcakes, adding natural maraschino cherries, and it was delicious. I followed the recipe, making my own cake flour, and I made sure not to over mix. I don't know how these cupcakes will make it to my son's Birthday party without being eaten. Delicious! I baked the cupcakes for 22 minutes.

Rating: 5 stars

05/14/2013

                Oh I forgot to add to my review what might have made the texture of the cake dry - they could have over mixed their batter.  The trick is to beat all the ingredients but not to over beat them.  


                    
                I made this cake the other night and it was SCRUMPTIOUS!  I know that a lot of the reviewers say that their cakes were dry, but mine turned out moist and very, very good.  I did however use "Cake Flour" instead of the "All-Purpose" which gave the cake a light and airy texture, but other than that I did exactly as Martha Stewart recipe directed.  Thanks Martha for yet another WONDERFULLY Delicious Recipe:-)

Rating: Unrated

04/27/2013

                Can not wait to try this recipe. I like the idea of doing basic cooking. Not alot of planning and work. Plus I don't really know alot of basics. so I really enjoy the classes. Keep them coming.

Rating: Unrated

08/21/2012

                I made this cake today following the recipe exactly. The cake came out nice. It's light  and fluffy. I like it, but I can understand some people think it's dry. They like really moist cakes. I guess it's all up to your preference. I will make this cake again.

Rating: Unrated

08/17/2012

                I just took the cake out; it took 30-35 min to bake. It's not a golden brown as my 7 up cakes are; the color is lighter, but I tested it with a toothpick and it's done - glad I did it, because it didn't look like it was done. I'll let you know how it tastes after I add the frosting and eat it, but it looks good.

Rating: Unrated

07/25/2012

                If you have a problem with dryness consider your cooling method. If possible leave this cake in the pan while cooling and drape a towel over it to prevent it from drying out. Also make sure not to overcook. I love this recipe. It has worked out much better than all the other yellow cake recipes I've found on the internet. If you need the pan immediately find some other method to cover your cake.

Rating: 3 stars

06/13/2012

                Did everyone cook it for only 30 min at 350? mine was not cooked at all i had to cook it for almost an hour.

Rating: 5 stars

06/09/2012

                I love this cake! I bake this cake for almost every occasion, my son's birthday party, etc.. I am really suprised there are so many bad reviews. I have never had a problem with the cake being dry. Everytime I make this cake everyone loves it. Watching foodnetwork and other baking shows I know they say if you over mix the batter it can make the cake dry along with over cooking it so that could be a problem? I always mix the batter just until the ingredients are mixed well and no more. Great cake!

Rating: Unrated

04/20/2012

                Just made this for the first time for my great nephew's birthday cake.  It is light and fluffy and full of old time, yellow cake taste.  If you follow the recipe as written, I don't know how you could get anything other than a yellow cake to rival any that my grandmother used to make.  It's delicious and easy to make.

Rating: Unrated

02/05/2012

                The secret is - cream butter and sugar really well - must be light and fluffy, have ALL ingredients at room temp, mix in dry ingredients until JUST incorporated - over-mixing will result in tough/dry cake.  I used 1 C milk and 1/4 C buttermilk, watch closely - do not overbake! It was moist and light - very tasty!

Rating: Unrated

01/31/2012

                This recipe was a huge disappointment. I tested the cake at 30 min and the center was a bit underdone so I left it in an additional 3 minutes.  Once the tester came out clean I took out of the oven straight away. It was an awful crumbly, dry mess. My time is valuable and I could have done better with a box mix. So, this will not be my go to yellow cake. Shame.

Rating: Unrated

12/26/2011

                Not exactly a review - a question.  Martha uses a bowl sifter - a terrific idea for a person with awful arthritis. But where can you get one like this, without little knobs and handles to hit your hands when you pat it to sift? thanks!

Rating: Unrated

10/07/2011

                Great simple recipe.  Using fresh eggs and butter will make the flavor amazing.  Lovely, delicately flavored cake, perfect for a birthday cake!

Rating: Unrated

09/10/2011

                I  think this is an excellent recipe and I have now idea why so many people found this to be dry.  It's light and moist and holds up well to slicing and filling.  The dryness in a cake is usually as a result of overcooking or cooking at too high a temperature.  I didn't follow the timing in recipes, as i always judge when a cake is ready by sight. I have an oven that runs a little hot; had I left it for 30 minutes, it would have been over-baked.  I can't wait to try the other variations.

Rating: Unrated

09/05/2011

                I followed the directions exactly and watched the time closely. It came out very dry and very dense. Can't think what could have happened. The flavor was good though. With ice cream piled on it was better. I used recipe from Martha's Baking Handbook which is exactly the same as this one. Wish I had read reviews here first :(

Rating: Unrated

09/03/2011

                in reading the reviews, i saw that some people had trouble with this cake being too dry... so i added an additional egg yolk. i also substituted vanilla soymilk for regular milk, just because that's what i had on hand. i turned this into cupcakes (and the recipe basically makes 24 normal size cupcakes perfectly). they came out SO delicious, light and fluffy.  i used a chocolate ganache instead of traditional icing and they are a huuuuge hit.

Rating: Unrated

07/04/2011

                Made this cake for the holidays and straight from the oven, it was an instant hit! It was delicious, soft and sufficiently moist. This receipe has become a family favorite and will surely be more than a season delight!

Rating: Unrated

07/01/2011

                Not only dry, but salty! Too much baking powder perhaps?  1 Tbsp seems excessive.  Also, the editor's note at the top of recipe is puzzling:  it suggests increasing the salt to 1 tsp if using 8" pans vs. 1/2 tsp for 9" pans --  doesn't seem logical.

Rating: Unrated

06/07/2011

                It's too dry.  I checked the cake at 30 mins (low side) and it was done!  Probably too done because it was a little on the dry side.  Comparing it to other recipes, I'm thinking I'll cut down 1/4 c. on the butter and add in 1/4 c. canola oil with the milk and trim 5-7 mins on baking

Rating: Unrated

04/27/2011

                I baked this cake today for a dinner party.   It came out a bit on the dry side, even though I was careful to watch the time (and pulled it out a little early just in case).

Rating: Unrated

02/27/2011

                This cake is delicious. It is very dense and holds up well for decorating or molding. I did not find it dry. Instead I felt it was a bit too sweet. So, I cut the sugar. It was a complete hit at my son's first birthday party.

Rating: Unrated

02/23/2011

                did not care for the texture or taste.  VERY DRY.  I  would add some sour cream.

Rating: Unrated

02/02/2011

                Hi Martha! Can you please give weight measurements in your recipes? Good luck with the new show, I'm hooked already

Rating: Unrated

02/01/2011

                I halved this recipe and made 14 cupcakes from the batter. I saw on America's Test Kitchen that they used bread flour when making cupcakes in order to make them a little sturdier for eating out of your hands, so I used AP flour and Bread flour instead of AP flour and Cake flour. They tasted wonderfully and weren't delicate for preschoolers hands. Perfect. I didn't think they were dry at all.

Rating: Unrated

04/27/2010

                A bit dry... good flavor though... but dry!

Rating: Unrated

04/06/2010

                This cake was tasty, but a little dry.

Rating: Unrated

03/19/2010

                Dear DessertFanatic, I too live at high altitude, if you reduce the baking powder to 2 teaspoons and add 1/4 teaspoon baking soda you should have no problem with the cake sinking and the texture will be improved. Also, if the cake was a little dry you may have overmixed slightly or bake a little to long. I hope this helps.

Rating: Unrated

03/14/2010

                I tried this cake recipe and it is good.  Moist and buttery tasting.    It didn't blow my socks off but it was still good.

Rating: Unrated

03/04/2010

                I was pretty disappointed with this recipe.  The crumb wasn't as fine and the texture wasn't as moist and light as I wanted it to be.  Also, if you live at high altitudes, you'll probably need to make some adjustments in the ingredients, because my cakes sunk slightly in the middle.  I just cut off the tops to level them anyway, but I just wanted perfection, and this cake didn't give me that.

Rating: Unrated

09/05/2009

                This cake is good.

Rating: Unrated

01/17/2009

                Just used a hand mixer and everything turned out fine.  I baked this with my 3 yr old's help.  We used a bundt cake pan instead and topped it with icing and fresh strawberries.  A very sophisticated 3rd bday cake (I must admit) but she loved that she made it herself.

All Reviews for Yellow Butter Cake

of Reviews

Reviews:

Most Helpful

Most Positive

Least Positive

Newest

All Reviews for Yellow Butter Cake

of Reviews

Reviews:

Most Helpful

Most Positive

Least Positive

Newest

Reviews:

Most Helpful

Most Positive

Least Positive

Newest

Gallery#

Recipe Summary#

Ingredients#

#

#

#

Gallery

Recipe Summary

Ingredients